American Association of Law Libraries · American Civil Liberties Union

American Immigration Lawyers Association · American Library Association

American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee · Americans for Democratic Action

Arab American Institute · Asian American Legal Defense and Education Fund

Association of Research Libraries · Center for Democracy and Technology

Children’s Environmental Health Network · Clean Production Network

Common Cause · Communications Workers of America

Cook Inlet Keeper · Council on American-Islamic Relations

Council on Professional Association of Federal Statistics · Electronic Frontier Foundation Electronic Privacy Information Center · Environmental Defense

Federation of American Scientists · Freedom of Information Center · Friends of the Earth Fund for Constitutional Government · Government Accountability Project · Greenpeace

Maryland Pesticide Network · National Environmental Trust

Natural Resources Defense Council · New Jersey Public Interest Research Group

New Jersey Work Environment Council · Ohio Citizen Action

Ohio Valley Environmental Coalition · OMB Watch · People for the American Way

Pesticide Action Network, North America · Powder River Basin Resource Council

Privacy Activism · Privacy Times · Project on Government Oversight

Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press · Sierra Club · Silicon Valley Toxics Coalition Society of Professional Journalists · Strategic Counsel on Corporate Accountability

U.S. Public Interest Research Group · University of Missouri School of Journalism

West Harlem Environmental Action · Working Group on Community Right-to-Know

 

FIX THE CRITICIAL INFRASTRUCUTRE INFORMATION SUBTITLE IN THE HOMELAND SECURITY ACT OF 2002

 

The undersigned organizations are concerned about the current language for Critical Infrastructure Information in the Homeland Security Act of 2002, which contains ambiguous definitions that could unintentionally allow companies to keep broad categories of information secret and provisions that restrict the government’s ability to use the information.  In order to better serve the goal of improving public safety and security, we support efforts to fix the Homeland Security Act by clarifying the scope of the information protected and removing provisions that overly restrict the government’s ability to use the information.

 

Senators Leahy (D-VT), Levin (D-MI), Jeffords (I-VT), Lieberman (D-CT), and Byrd (D-WV) will soon introduce legislation entitled the Restoration of Freedom of Information Act of 2003 (“Restore FOIA”) addressing these concerns, using bipartisan language developed last year by the Senate Governmental Affairs Committee.  The Restore FOIA solution would:

 

  • Clarify the FOIA exemption to be more consistent with established law.
  • Remove the restrictions on the government’s ability to act as it sees fit in response to the information it receives. 
  • Preserve whistleblower protections by removing unnecessary criminal penalties.

 

The information provisions currently within the Homeland Security Act of 2002 do not accomplish the goal of the law -- empowering the government to protect citizens using private-sector information which is “voluntarily” shared and identifies potential vulnerabilities to terrorist attacks.  The current language could have devastating effects on the work of the government to protect public health, safety and security, as well as government accountability. It is essential that these problems in the Homeland Security Act be fixed immediately before they become too firmly entrenched in the law. 

 

 

 

 


Jean AbiNader

Managing Director

Arab American Institute

 

Prudence S. Adler

Associate Executive Director

Association of Research Libraries

 

Steven Aftergood

Project Director

Federation of American Scientists

 

Gary Bass

Executive Director

OMB Watch

 

Jeremiah Baumann

Director, Toxics Right to Know Campaign

U.S. Public Interest Research Group

 

Ruth Berlin

Executive Director

MD Pesticide Network

 

Lynne Bradley

Director, Government Relations

American Library Association

 

Danielle Brian

Executive Director

Project on Government Oversight

 

Sandy Buchanan

Executive Director

Ohio Citizen Action

 

Jeanne Butterfield

Executive Director

American Immigration Lawyers Association

 

Alyssondra Campaigne

Legislative Director

Natural Resources Defense Council

 

Kevin S. Curtis

Vice President - Government Affairs

National Environmental Trust

 

Lucy Dalglish

Executive Director

Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press

 

Charles N. Davis

Executive Director

Freedom of Information Center

University of Missouri School of Journalism

 

Tom Devine

Legal Director

Government Accountability Project

Rick Engler

Director

New Jersey Work Environment Council

 

Jason Erb

Director, Governmental Relations

Council on American-Islamic Relations

 

Darryl Fagin

Legislative Director

Americans for Democratic Action

 

Margaret Fung

Executive Director

Asian American Legal Defense and Education Fund

 

Vickie Goodwin

Organizer

Powder River Basin Resource Council

 

Evan Hendricks

Editor/Publisher

Privacy Times

 

Rick Hind

Legislative Director

Greenpeace

 

Khalil Jahshan

Director of Government Affairs

American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee

 

Susan E. Kegley

Staff Scientist/Program Coordinator

Pesticide Action Network, North America

 

Robert Leger

President

Society of Professional Journalists

 

Dave LeGrande

Director, Occupational Safety & Health

CWA/AFL-CIO

 

Sanford Lewis

Director

Strategic Counsel on Corporate Accountability

 

Conrad Martin

Executive Director

Fund for Constitutional Government

 

Alexandra McPherson

Director

Clean Production Action

 

Dena Mottola

Acting Director

New Jersey Public Interest Research Group

 

Laura W. Murphy

Director, Washington National Office

American Civil Liberties Union

 

Ralph G. Neas

President

People for the American Way

 

Robert Oakley

Washington Affairs Representative

American Association of Law Libraries

 

Paul Orum

Director

Working Group on Community Right-to-Know

 

Deborah Pierce

Executive Director

Privacy Activism

 

Chellie Pingree

President and CEO

Common Cause

 

Ari Schwartz

Associate Director

Center for Democracy and Technology

 

Debbie Sease

Legislative Director

Sierra Club

 

Bob Shavelson

Executive Director

Cook Inlet Keeper

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Peggy M. Shepard

Executive Director

West Harlem Environmental Action

 

Ted Smith

Executive Director

Silicon Valley Toxics Coalition

 

David Sobel

General Counsel

Electronic Privacy Information Center

 

Ed Spar

Executive Director

Council on Professional Association of Federal Statistics

 

Vivian Stockman

Communications Coordinator

Ohio Valley Environmental Coalition

 

Daniel Swartz

Executive Director

Children’s Environmental Health Network

 

Lee Tien

Senior Staff Attorney

Electronic Frontier Foundation

 

Elizabeth Thompson

Legislative Director

Environmental Defense

 

Sara Zdeb

Legislative Director

Friends of the Earth